Brookhaven, NY, USA Vacation rentals • comparison for Airbnb, Vrbo and Booking prices

United States New York Ocean Bay Park vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 32593838

Windows on the Sea ★ Modern Pool & Beach Retreat ★

5.0 (71)

5 Bedrooms • 12 Guests

$1,182 avg/night

United States Connecticut East Hampton vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 24955564

Fun on the Lake: Games, Dock, Slide, EV Charger

5.0 (104)

3 Bedrooms • 8 Guests

$488 avg/night

United States New York Fire Island vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 240278

Oceanfront Heaven! - 5 BR

5.0 (83)

5 Bedrooms • 12 Guests

$1,957 avg/night

United States Connecticut Milford vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 686868

Waterfront!-Hot Tub-The Charles Island Beach House

5.0 (103)

4 Bedrooms • 12 Guests

$1,363 avg/night

United States Connecticut Milford vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 27242009

Fantastic BEACH House The Whales Tale Summer 2026

5.0 (1)

4 Bedrooms • 8 Guests

$1,184 avg/night

ShakaCodedata

Curious how HiChee gets its data?

ShakaCode scrapes. So you don't have to.

Delegate all scraping burden to us. Get the data you need. Focus on your primary goals.

Learn More

United States Connecticut East Lyme vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 33535554

Niantic Cove Waterfront Escape: Relax & Unwind

5.0 (17)

2 Bedrooms • 6 Guests

Available on

United States Connecticut Norwalk vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 4376094

The Boathouse on Five Mile River

5.0 (41)

4 Bedrooms • 7 Guests

$1,784 avg/night

United States New York Wading River vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 29622240

Coastal Retreat Waterfront, Deck, Awesome Views

5.0 (36)

3 Bedrooms • 6 Guests

$259 avg/night

United States New York Hampton Bays vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 15406013

Poppy’s Hampton House | 3BR + Bonus | Near Beach

4.9 (23)

3 Bedrooms • 6 Guests

$275 avg/night

United States New York Mattituck vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 32295970

Nature’s Paradise | Private Dock & Water Views

4.9 (35)

4 Bedrooms • 9 Guests

$1,066 avg/night

United States New York Southold vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 11399584

Shorecrest Beach House + Beach Front + Ocean views

4.9 (31)

4 Bedrooms • 10 Guests

$47 avg/night

United States New York Southampton vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 246904

Shinnecock Retreat | Heated Pool & Hot Tub

4.9 (6)

3 Bedrooms • 6 Guests

Available on

United States New York Wading River vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 29973652

Sea Cliff Charm | 5 Min to Beach, Fire Pit & BBQ

4.9 (16)

3 Bedrooms • 4 Guests

Available on

United States New York Wading River vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 10184035

Lindsay Estate | Furnished Pool & Hot Tub

4.9 (52)

4 Bedrooms • 9 Guests

$1,035 avg/night

United States New York Rocky Point vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 228821

Dunes Beach House: Hot Tub and Steps to Beach

4.8 (13)

2 Bedrooms • 6 Guests

Available on

United States New York Mattituck vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 23585329

Respite Ranch | Pool, Hot Tub & North Fork

4.8 (19)

3 Bedrooms • 6 Guests

$396 avg/night

United States New York Peconic vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 9357963

Peconic Sound Beach Cottage | Walk to Sound

4.8 (21)

3 Bedrooms • 7 Guests

$247 avg/night

United States New York Wading River vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 33576703

After Dune Delight Beach Cottage | Steps to Shore

4.8 (9)

2 Bedrooms • 4 Guests

$216 avg/night

United States New York Hampton Bays vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 33542097

Bay Beach House: *New Pool, Hot Tub + Bikes

4.8 (13)

3 Bedrooms • 7 Guests

$1,447 avg/night

United States Connecticut New Haven vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 36848849

3BR Home Near Yale & Tweed Airport

4.8 (38)

3 Bedrooms • 8 Guests

$308 avg/night

United States Connecticut Redding vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 25981298

Meeker Hill House - Country Escape w/ Heated Pool

4.8 (21)

3 Bedrooms • 6 Guests

$963 avg/night

United States Connecticut Southbury vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 35674821

Private Apartment in Southbury 102

4.7 (21)

1 Bedroom • 2 Guests

$163 avg/night

United States New York Southampton vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 25025586

Southampton Pool Home Near Village & Shinnecock

4.7 (6)

4 Bedrooms • 8 Guests

Available on

United States New York Wading River vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 11539589

Rustic Beachfront Cottage with Private Beach

4.7 (93)

1 Bedroom • 4 Guests

$700 avg/night

United States Connecticut Milford vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 35686234

Beach Apartment in Woodmont Milford

4.6 (19)

3 Bedrooms • 6 Guests

$246 avg/night

1 2 3 4 5

Compare Airbnb vs. Booking.com vs. Vrbo prices for vacation rentals in Brookhaven, NY, USA

Check it before you book it! ™