Shelter Island Heights, NY, USA Vacation Rentals | 

Price Comparison Results
Listings
Listings
Open on
Open search on
United States New York Greenport vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 12949652
4.7 (111)
The Menhaden Hotel
Up to 2 guests
Booking.com$483
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York Greenport vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 38273814
4.7 (110)
The Menhaden Hotel
Up to 3 guests
Booking.com$439
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York Greenport vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 38273869
4.7 (111)
The Menhaden Hotel
Up to 4 guests
Booking.com$483
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York East Marion vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 12841155
4.6 (12)
Arbor View House Bed and Breakfast
Up to 2 guests
Booking.com$548
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York East Marion vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 12975580
4.6 (12)
Arbor View House Bed and Breakfast
Up to 2 guests
Booking.com$442
Average Nightly Rate
HiChee Chrome Extension

Use our Chrome Extension. It's Free!

Get instant price-comparison savings while browsing Airbnb, Booking.com, and Vrbo!

United States New York Southold vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 12866076
4.5 (14)
Historic White Blossom House
Up to 6 guests
Booking.com$472
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York Greenport vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 12938803
4.5 (138)
American Beech Hotel
Up to 4 guests
Booking.com$298
Average Nightly Rate

Curious howHiCheeLogoColorfulgets its data?

ShakaCode Data logoShakaCodedata

ShakaCode scrapes. So you don't have to.

Delegate your web scraping needs to us. Get the data you need.
Focus on your primary goals.

HiCheeLogoColorfulHiChee is built and owned byShakaCode logoShakaCode

Learn more
United States New York Greenport vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 13430371
4.5 (138)
American Beech Hotel
Up to 2 guests
Booking.com$298
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York Greenport vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 13431347
4.5 (138)
American Beech Hotel
Up to 2 guests
Booking.com$298
Average Nightly Rate

Smarter Planning with Watchlists

Create your Watchlists boards and see price comparisons for multiple listings at once. You'll also get notified about price and availability changes and can share it with others.

HiChee Watchlists
United States New York Southold vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 15061814
4.5 (55)
The Shoals Suites & Slips
Up to 4 guests
Booking.com$393
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York Greenport vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 19441524
4.5 (141)
American Beech Hotel
Up to 2 guests
Booking.com$361
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York East Hampton vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 36586474
4.5 (4)
Heated Pool, Driftwood Cottage by RoveTravel
Up to 7 guests
Booking.com$579
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York Sag Harbor vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 36814482
4.5 (1)
Getaway House at Sag Harbor
Up to 6 guests
Booking.com$1,270
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York Greenport vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 12765978
4.5 (251)
The Cliffside Resort Condominiums
Up to 6 guests
Booking.com$289
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York Greenport vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 12890749
4.5 (251)
The Cliffside Resort Condominiums
Up to 6 guests
Booking.com$289
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York Greenport vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 12969472
4.5 (250)
The Cliffside Resort Condominiums
Up to 6 guests
Booking.com$295
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York Greenport vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 12979938
4.5 (251)
The Cliffside Resort Condominiums
Up to 6 guests
Booking.com$289
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York East Hampton vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 14618509
4.5 (240)
East Hampton House Resort
Up to 4 guests
Booking.com$206
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York East Hampton vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 14922483
4.5 (244)
East Hampton House Resort
Up to 4 guests
Booking.com$214
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York East Hampton vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 14994852
4.5 (242)
East Hampton House Resort
Up to 4 guests
Booking.com$237
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York East Hampton vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 15015548
4.5 (240)
East Hampton House Resort
Up to 4 guests
Booking.com$206
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York East Hampton vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 16132849
4.5 (242)
East Hampton House Resort
Up to 4 guests
Booking.com$237
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York East Hampton vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 16138789
4.5 (242)
East Hampton House Resort
Up to 4 guests
Booking.com$237
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York East Hampton vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 16155220
4.5 (243)
East Hampton House Resort
Up to 3 guests
Booking.com$237
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York East Hampton vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 16183994
4.5 (244)
East Hampton House Resort
Up to 4 guests
Booking.com$214
Average Nightly Rate
Angle left icon123456Angle left icon
  1. United States
  2. New York
  3. Shelter Island Heights Vacation Rental Price Comparison

Compare Airbnb vs. Booking.com vs. Vrbo prices for vacation rentals in Shelter Island Heights, NY, USA

© 2025 HiChee.com. All Rights Reserved.

Check it before you book it! ™

Privacy PolicyTerms of Service