Shelter Island Heights, NY, USA Vacation Rentals | 

Price Comparison Results
Listings
Listings
Open on
Open search on
United States New York Greenport vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 35941144
4.9 (17)
Harbor Knoll Bed and Breakfast
Up to 3 guests
Booking.com$509
Airbnb
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York Peconic vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 35336593
5.0 (1)
Peconic Sound Beach Home: Backyard & Vineyards
Up to 7 guests
Booking.com$691
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York East Hampton vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 36586476
5.0 (1)
Brightwater by Rove Villa with Sauna Pool and Outdoor Spaces
Up to 14 guests
Booking.com$1,614
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York East Hampton vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 36623497
5.0 (2)
Private Home near Ocean Beaches, Nature Preserve
Up to 3 guests
Booking.com$860
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York Shelter Island Heights vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 12828674
5.0 (75)
Seven Resort Style Inn near Beach
Up to 2 guests
Booking.com$427
Average Nightly Rate
HiChee Chrome Extension

Use our Chrome Extension. It's Free!

Get instant price-comparison savings while browsing Airbnb, Booking.com, and Vrbo!

United States New York Greenport vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 18093080
5.0 (17)
Harbor Knoll Bed and Breakfast
Up to 2 guests
Booking.com$564
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York Greenport vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 12969720
4.9 (17)
Harbor Knoll Bed and Breakfast
Up to 2 guests
Booking.com$516
Average Nightly Rate

Curious howHiCheeLogoColorfulgets its data?

ShakaCode Data logoShakaCodedata

ShakaCode scrapes. So you don't have to.

Delegate your web scraping needs to us. Get the data you need.
Focus on your primary goals.

HiCheeLogoColorfulHiChee is built and owned byShakaCode logoShakaCode

Learn more
United States New York Shelter Island Heights vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 13408400
4.9 (73)
Seven Resort Style Inn near Beach
Up to 2 guests
Booking.com$728
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York Greenport vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 18284381
4.9 (17)
Harbor Knoll Bed and Breakfast
Up to 2 guests
Booking.com$506
Average Nightly Rate

Smarter Planning with Watchlists

Create your Watchlists boards and see price comparisons for multiple listings at once. You'll also get notified about price and availability changes and can share it with others.

HiChee Watchlists
United States New York East Hampton vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 12820446
4.8 (17)
East Hampton Art House Bed and Breakfast
Up to 4 guests
Booking.com$565
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York East Hampton vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 12971164
4.8 (17)
East Hampton Art House Bed and Breakfast
Up to 3 guests
Booking.com$565
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York East Hampton vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 14924521
4.8 (17)
East Hampton Art House Bed and Breakfast
Up to 4 guests
Booking.com$565
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York Greenport vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 36265173
4.8 (110)
Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows
Up to 2 guests
Booking.com$393
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York Greenport vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 36265176
4.8 (110)
Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows
Up to 2 guests
Booking.com$339
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York Greenport vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 36265179
4.8 (110)
Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows
Up to 4 guests
Booking.com$414
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York Greenport vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 36265183
4.8 (110)
Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows
Up to 2 guests
Booking.com$414
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York Greenport vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 36265185
4.8 (110)
Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows
Up to 2 guests
Booking.com$339
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York Greenport vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 36265186
4.8 (110)
Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows
Up to 2 guests
Booking.com$414
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York Greenport vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 36265187
4.8 (110)
Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows
Up to 4 guests
Booking.com$393
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York Greenport vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 36265191
4.8 (110)
Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows
Up to 2 guests
Booking.com$339
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York Greenport vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 36265432
4.8 (110)
Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows
Up to 2 guests
Booking.com$415
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York Greenport vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 36265435
4.8 (110)
Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows
Up to 2 guests
Booking.com$414
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York Southold vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 12788335
4.8 (18)
A Walk in the Woods Bed and Breakfast
Up to 2 guests
Booking.com$363
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York Southold vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 15122701
4.8 (18)
A Walk in the Woods Bed and Breakfast
Up to 2 guests
Booking.com$373
Average Nightly Rate
United States New York Greenport vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 12751438
4.7 (111)
The Menhaden Hotel
Up to 2 guests
Booking.com$439
Average Nightly Rate
Angle left icon123456Angle left icon
  1. United States
  2. New York
  3. Shelter Island Heights Vacation Rental Price Comparison

Compare Airbnb vs. Booking.com vs. Vrbo prices for vacation rentals in Shelter Island Heights, NY, USA

© 2025 HiChee.com. All Rights Reserved.

Check it before you book it! ™

Privacy PolicyTerms of Service