Buffalo, IN, USA Vacation Rentals

United States Indiana Monticello vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 195786

Lakefront Cottage w/ Deck Near Indiana Beach!

4.9 (48)

2 Bedrooms • 4 Guests

$335 avg/night

United States Indiana Monticello vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 245021

Waterfront Monticello Home w/ Fire Pit & Deck!

4.9 (200)

3 Bedrooms • 9 Guests

Available on

United States Indiana Monticello vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 2422898

1 bedroom + Sleeping Alcove Cottage #8

4 Bedrooms • 8 Guests

Available on

United States Indiana Monticello vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 1831164

Two bedrooms Cottage #1 Perfect for Families!

5.0 (10)

2 Bedrooms • 6 Guests

$222 avg/night

ShakaCodedata

Curious how HiChee gets its data?

ShakaCode scrapes. So you don't have to.

Delegate all scraping burden to us. Get the data you need. Focus on your primary goals.

Learn More

United States Indiana Monticello vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 26608161

Studio unit with kitchenette #2

5.0 (9)

1 Bedroom • 2 Guests

$139 avg/night

United States Indiana Monticello vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 44539464

Relaxing lake front 2 bedroom 1 bath home

4.9 (15)

2 Bedrooms • 5 Guests

$278 avg/night

United States Indiana Monticello vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 2393844

Studio unit with kitchenette #11

4.7 (20)

1 Bedroom • 2 Guests

$147 avg/night

United States Indiana Monticello vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 2355349

2 Bedroom + 2 Sleeping Alcoves Perfect For a Group

4.0 (2)

2 Bedrooms • 8 Guests

Available on

United States Indiana Monticello vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 10129849

Two bedrooms Cottage #10 Perfect for Families!

3.0 (2)

2 Bedrooms • 6 Guests

Available on

United States Indiana Monticello vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 38399273

Lakeside Haven: 4 bed/2 bath/sleep 11 on the water

5.0 (35)

4 Bedrooms • 11 Guests

Available on

United States Indiana Monticello vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 39453944

Bailey Bungalow Lake house

4.8 (32)

3 Bedrooms • 8 Guests

Available on

United States Indiana Monticello vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 472287

Year Round Lake Home with Wonderful Lake Frontage

4.8 (199)

3 Bedrooms • 12 Guests

Available on

United States Indiana Monticello vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 2439389

Gorgeous lake front cottage. Enjoy those summer nights on the lake

5.0 (20)

3 Bedrooms • 8 Guests

Available on

United States Indiana Monticello vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 31318935

A peaceful retreat, come relax on Lake Shafer. Fire pit, kayaks & games.

5.0 (15)

3 Bedrooms • 10 Guests

Available on

United States Indiana Monticello vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 38026305

Quiet & Serene Waterfront Condo Fit for a King

5.0 (27)

2 Bedrooms • 6 Guests

$221 avg/night

United States Indiana Monticello vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 39474180

Firefly at Lake Shafer

5.0 (12)

2 Bedrooms • 4 Guests

Available on

United States Indiana Monticello vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 40921806

*Casa Azul*Lakefront-Hot Tub-Bar-Game Room-Boathouse

5.0 (21)

7 Bedrooms • 12 Guests

$1,642 avg/night

United States Indiana Monon vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 44524609

Lucretia's Lakeside

5.0 (1)

2 Bedrooms • 6 Guests

Available on

United States Indiana Monticello vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 44575742

Riverside Reflections Home

5.0 (11)

2 Bedrooms • 8 Guests

$244 avg/night

United States Indiana Monticello vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 37859346

Family Fun or Serene Setting?

5.0 (29)

2 Bedrooms • 8 Guests

$277 avg/night

United States Indiana Monticello vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 27733603

Mellow Yellow on Shafer

5.0 (19)

4 Bedrooms • 12 Guests

$1,188 avg/night

United States Indiana Monon vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 39078619

Lucretia’s Lakeside

4.6 (11)

2 Bedrooms • 5 Guests

$158 avg/night

United States Indiana Monticello vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 40533536

Memorable on Monon Bay

4.5 (4)

3 Bedrooms • 6 Guests

$266 avg/night

United States Indiana Monticello vacation rental compare prices direct by owner 40683932

Lake Shafer Country Cottage with Magnificent View

4.4 (9)

2 Bedrooms • 5 Guests

Available on

1 2

Compare Airbnb vs. Booking.com vs. Vrbo prices for vacation rentals in Buffalo, IN, USA

Check it before you book it! ™