Lake Ontario Motel proudly offers cozy accommodations near Niagara Falls in Western New York. Located in Niagara County, our motel rests in a cozy atmosphere that is conveniently located near restaurants and shopping. Located in Newfane, NY, this is a quiet, relaxing place to stay while visiting Niagara Falls. We are located near the western end of Lake Ontario. Located six miles from the world class salmon and trout fishing in Lake Ontario and four miles from Eighteen Mile Creek. Other things to note Pet fee is an additional $25 a night and a credit card on file at check-in.