Price Comparison Results
1825 Farmhouse - One of Three Rentals in Fly Creek
1825 Farmhouse - One of Three Rentals in Fly Creek, 5 minutes from Cooperstown
Other Booking Options
Upgrade your account to get better deals with book-direct options and access manager contact information.
What Guests Say
Guests consistently note clean, spacious, comfortable stays. The location near Cooperstown, Fly Creek, and Dreams Park is a clear plus. Hosts are responsive and the property offers a family-friendly fire pit and yard.
Pros
- Clean, spacious, and comfortable throughout
- Prime location near Cooperstown, Fly Creek, Dreams Park
- Large yard with a fire pit, family-friendly
- Very responsive, helpful hosts
- Well-equipped kitchen and thoughtful extras
Cons
- Hidden primary driveway can be easy to miss
- Furniture is dated but usable
- Not very private; adjacent unit near you
Other Notes
- Site includes multiple rentals; guests often felt private despite shared spaces.
- Primary driveway is hard to locate; follow host directions.
- Hosts are responsive and accommodating; minor issues resolved quickly.
From the Host
Step into a historic farmhouse with an original staircase and warm, patinaed wood that invites you to slow down. A covered patio opens to the grounds and a large eat-in kitchen becomes the hub for family meals, while a shared fire pit offers evenings under the stars. A footpath leads to the nearby Cider Mill, adding a sense of place to your stay. This grounded, unpretentious retreat sits near Cooperstown, offering a genuine place to gather and unwind.
Nearby Highlights
- Fenimore Art Museum(20 min drive)
Impressive collection of American folk art and rotating exhibits in Cooperstown.
- National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum(20 min drive)
Explore baseball history and exhibits at one of America's iconic sports venues.
- Glimmerglass State Park(15 min drive)
Scenic lake trails and picnic areas along Otsego Lake.
- Ommegang Brewery(20 min drive)
Guided tours, beer tastings, and seasonal food pairings.
- The Farmers' Museum(15 min drive)
Living history exhibits and rural life recreated in a 19th century village.
- Howes Cave(30 min drive)
Underground tours of a limestone cave with crystal formations.
Description
1825 Farmhouse - One of Three Rentals in Fly Creek, 5 minutes from Cooperstown The space ***This Property Books on Cooperstown Dreams Park calendar only! 1825 Farmhouse - The frame of the 1825 Farmhouse was built at the same time as the 1825 Cottage (neighboring rental). The original staircase has been retained and refinished, showing the patina and warmth that only aged wood provides. A covered patio that looks out over the 35 acres is ideal for outdoor dining and relaxing. This home features a large eat-in kitchen- a favorite place for families to cook and enjoy the camaraderie. There is one bedroom and a bath on the first floor; there are 3 bedrooms and a full bath plus a half bath on the second floor. Three rental homes share the 35-acre well-maintained grounds. There is a scenic pond and a fire pit that is shared - build a fire and swap baseball philosophies under the peaceful stars. This property borders the Fly Creek Cider Mill and your host maintains a footpath to the Cider Mill. Check out nearby properties by the same host: 1825 Cottage and 1825 Farmhouse. Mileage: Cooperstown Dreams Park - 7.0 miles All Star Village - 23.5 miles Baseball Hall of Fame - 3.5 miles Please note: NO smoking NO pets NO team parties or large gatherings A refundable Damage Deposit will be requested for this property. This is separate from the rental fee.
Community Book-Direct Links
Reviews
Location
United States · New York · Fly Creek
Got questions?
We are eager to hear from you whether you need to contact our support team, speak with our founders, or simply want to say hello.